Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plastic dome container

Anderson's Frozen Custard recalled Andersons Pumpkin Pie ice cream pie, 8 inch round ice cream pie with whipped frosting --- The pie is packaged in a 9 inch round clear plast in a Class I action — the FDA's most serious tier, reserved for products with a reasonable probability of causing serious health consequences or death on Nov 23, 2016.

The FDA listed the reason as an undeclared allergen: "The Pumpkin Ice Cream Pies may contain undeclared peanuts." Allergen mislabeling is the leading cause of U.S. food recalls, because a missing declaration can trigger a reaction in someone who reads the label and believes the product is safe.

Distribution was limited; the FDA record lists "New York." Single-area recalls still warrant a kitchen check for anyone who shops within that footprint. The recalling firm is based in Williamsville, NY. The recall covers 102 pies of product. The FDA has Terminated this recall (first reported Jan 18, 2017), its final lifecycle state, indicating the agency considers the corrective action resolved. The historical record remains useful for tracking a brand's recall pattern over time.