Skip to main content
FoodRecallWatch
Class II, May Cause HarmF-1103-2014

Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie Premium Ice Cream 48 oz. packaged in a paper tub and lid, distributed by Turkey Hill Dairy, Conestoga, PA.

Recalled by Turkey Hill Dairy, INC. on Oct 4, 2013

Reviewed by FoodRecallWatch Editorial Team · Updated

Recall Summary

Turkey Hill Dairy, INC. recalled Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie Premium Ice Cream in a Class II action, the FDA tier for products that may cause temporary or medically reversible health effects on Oct 4, 2013.

The recall cites foreign-material contamination: "Turkey Hill Dairy is initiating a voluntary recall on Turkey Hill Ice Cream because the product may be potentially contaminated with metal debris." Physical contaminants such as metal, glass, or plastic can cause choking, cuts, or dental injuries.

The product reached multiple states, recorded by the FDA as "MA, MD, PA." A multi-state footprint means the same lot can surface in households far from the producer. The recalling firm is based in Conestoga, PA. The recall covers 756 tubs of product. The FDA has Terminated this recall (first reported Dec 25, 2013), its final lifecycle state, indicating the agency considers the corrective action resolved. The historical record remains useful for tracking a brand's recall pattern over time.

Reason for Recall

Turkey Hill Dairy is initiating a voluntary recall on Turkey Hill Ice Cream because the product may be potentially contaminated with metal debris.

Product Description

Turkey Hill Pumpkin Pie Premium Ice Cream 48 oz. packaged in a paper tub and lid, distributed by Turkey Hill Dairy, Conestoga, PA.

Distribution

MA, MD, PA

What Should You Do?

  • 1.Check your kitchen for this product immediately.
  • 2.Do not consume the recalled product.
  • 3.Return the product to where you bought it for a full refund, or throw it away.
  • 4.If you have experienced any health issues, contact your healthcare provider.

Browse Related Recalls

Terms Explained

Source: FDA Recalls, Market Withdrawals and Safety Alerts, 2026.